With club cricket bracing for an ugly flashpoint this summer due to the rise in Mankad incidents, some leagues are discussing banning dismissals entirely.
There has been a flurry of high-profile incidents in the professional game in recent months, and there are fears that this will inevitably trickle down to the recreational game, where there are already disciplinary issues on the field.
In cricket clubs in both Australia and South Africa, Mankad was recently sacked, with footage circulating on social media of an angry confrontation during a club match in Victoria.
Mankad is becoming more and more widely accepted in the professional game and there have been many incidents over the past few months. England’s Charlie Dean was knocked out by India’s Deepti Shah at Lords Stadium in September, while Mitchell Starc was cautioned during the Boxing Day Test A South African batsman. This was recently seen in the Big Bash and the Women’s Under-19 World Cup.
The fear is that this could lead to confrontations among English cricket clubs this summer, especially as umpires are confused by the recent clarification of the law.
The MCC recently added two sub-clauses to the law to clarify when a bowler can run out of non-strikers. It states that when a pitcher reaches “the apex of his/her normal pitching motion in the pitching swing,” running may be affected.
A senior club official has expressed doubts that club referees will be able to oversee that, and expects incidents to erupt this summer, putting more pressure on officials who have already reported increased levels of abuse.
“I’m not quite sure how we expect umpires to be able to monitor whether a bowler has gone past the pitch. The farther we go, the wilder the West becomes, and people worry that something like Mancad will divide opinion,” said the National Cricket Conference. Managing Director Simon Prodger said. “Referees may want to interpret things in the spirit of the game, but feel pressured to make decisions that could lead to aggravation because the law states that Mankad is a legal form of dismissal.
“The problem in a club cricket environment is that the umpire is able to explain whether the mankad process has been done correctly. It’s not easy. He’s looking at the front foot and trying to determine whether the bowler’s process has done the run correctly or not, which is going to be difficult. “
telegram sports The Association of Cricket Officials, an arm of the England and Wales Cricket Board, is understood to be briefing umpires on the legal changes ahead of the start of the season.
But the concern is that many games below the top-tier recreational competition are officiated by qualified umpires, which could prompt league officials to decide it would be easier to ban sacks to avoid confrontations.
“We have to admit that most refereeing of amateur games tends to be done by unqualified officials. Further down the league structure, players refereeing their own games or club members who are not qualified to officiate do so out of good intentions,” Prodger said.
“You can see the tendency of Mankadin to become a major problem and cause major flashpoints. A little. You’re likely to have situations where individual leagues decide to ban Mankadin even though it’s within the rules. The leagues are taking this seriously and are prepared to unilaterally decide to operate on what happens in their games.”
Ex-England batsman Mark Butcher voiced the same concern last week on his podcast with Wisden. “If people start doing it for granted in club games, I can see absolute carnage happening in this land and many other places,” he said.
“Because there’s very little regulation in terms of how people behave and how the game is played, and the game has been going on for years and the players are refereeing their own players and stuff like that.”
If the league bans Mankad, hitters will be able to get a head start without fear of being knocked out. This would have to be self-regulated, leading to even more potential problems.